Vanitas Paintings; Or, Eclessiastical Ponderings
A Vanitas is a still life painting from the Dutch Golden Age (1575-1675) that reminds us that life is finite and that worldly goods and pleasures are transient, ultimately worthless after death. Its namesake comes from the Book of Ecclesiastes:
vanitas vanitatum, omnia vanitas.
The Latin phrase translates to “vanity of vanities, all is vanity.”
Vanitas paintings are full of symbols of death and worldliness: typically skulls, bones, butterflies, bubbles, musical instruments, shells, jewelry, crowns, swords, cups, flowers, fruit, timepieces like watches and hourglasses, knives, and medical tools. The objects are crammed together in a disorderly fashion (which you can logically connect to our favorite vampire doctor if you like.)
The following is a list of symbol meanings reproduced from artseed.art:
- Skull – The fragility of life and the inevitability of mortality.
- Rotten fruit – Aging and the passing of time. Mature fruits mean fertility and wealth, due to the abundance of being able to let fruit go rotten. Different fruits have different connotations, such as apples, tomatoes, grapes, peaches, and pears meaning the fall of man.
- Peaches – symbolizes truth and salvation.
- Apple – wisdom, yet temptation and original sin.
- Watch, Hourglass or Timepiece – the transience and limitation of time.
- Books – human curiosity and knowledge, and the limitations and temporary nature of this.
- Shells – a sense of exoticism and wealth, as they were not commonly found in the Netherlands, where Vanitas paintings originated. Only the very wealthy would be able to afford exotic items such as shells, therefore they represent a sense of vanity and uncouth ostentatiousness. Also, a sign of death and frailty, as shells were often once homes for a living animal.
- Decaying Flowers – the decay of the body, and the inevitable mortality of human nature. Decaying flowers were often included in works with a variety of rich objects which depicted wealth, to contrast the beauty of wealth with the inevitability of impending death. Different flowers symbolize different virtues:
- Rose – love, sensuality, vanity
- Poppy – mortal sin and laziness, due to its opiate properties
- Tulip – irresponsibility, naivety, and foolishness.
- Silk and velvet materials – symbolize vanity. Silk and velvet were expensive materials, which were exclusive to the richest members of society.
- Oriental rugs or carpets – symbolize wealth. These were exclusive and expensive items, which were placed on tables to protect the color and quality of the wood. They were also an industrious symbol, as they were brought to Northern Europe through trade and business.
- Jewelry or Clothing – the temporal nature of beauty, and the sin of narcissism. They symbolize the transience of the beauty of the body and the nature of wisdom in human life. Earthly riches are important in life, but soon mean little once life is over.
- Mirror – a clear symbol of vanity and self–reflection.
- Candle or Lamp – the human soul. It’s loss or blowing out symbolizes the loss of the soul and the transience of life.
- Cups, playing cards, dice or chess – sign of faulty life goals, finding pleasures in sin.
- Arms and Armor – authority and power. A sign of earthly power and designations that mean little in the afterlife.
- Glass – an empty glass symbolizes death. Glass also connotes fragility, whilst white porcelain represents purity. A bottle symbolizes drunkenness and uncouth behavior.
- Knife – human vulnerability and mortality.
- Medical Tools – a reminder of the fleshy reality of the human body, and its multiple possibilities to fail.
Besides Artseed's Vanitas still life document, I also referred to The Collector’s article
Vanitas: Dutch Master Paintings Explained
. See the links below:
Sundry Victorian Symbolism; Odds & Ends
Jun Mochizuki used Victorian flower language throughout the entirety of
Pandora Hearts
, and judging by the contents of the volume covers, she hasn’t stopped this practice as of yet. An exhaustive list of flower meanings is too long for the amount of effort I intend to put in this section, so I will leave a note on the references used instead.
The lion’s share of flower language meaning was obtained from
Occasional Papers from The RHS Lindley Library
, Volume 10 (April 2013), of the Royal Horticultural Society. I only used the table on pp. 52-94 as it conveniently listed the flower meanings.
In addition to the flower meanings, I used Vintage View’s glossary of Victorian Cemetery Symbolism for volume cover analysis. This was helpful in illuminating the symbols not covered by Vanitas paintings or flower symbolism. Also of help was the United States Genealogy & History Network’s Tombstone Symbols & Their Meanings. See the links below:
The Catholic Encyclopedia from New Advent was used for volume 3’s combined Vanitas/Noé monstrance. See the link below:
Ecclesiastes 1:1–11
The Case Study of Vanitas
has its own fair share of Biblical references. The most obvious example is Vanitas' name, character arc, and design originating with Dutch vanitas paintings. The "vanitas" in question originates from the famous verse in Ecclesiastes, a brutal judgment on the nature of life on earth.
- The words of the Preacher, the son of David, king in Jerusalem.
- Vanity of vanities, saith the Preacher, vanity of vanities; all is vanity.
- What profit hath a man of all his labour which he taketh under the sun?
- One generation passeth away, and another generation cometh: but the earth abideth for ever.
- The sun also ariseth, and the sun goeth down, and hasteth to his place where he arose.
- The wind goeth toward the south, and turneth about unto the north; it whirleth about continually, and the wind returneth again according to his circuits.
- All the rivers run into the sea; yet the sea is not full; unto the place from whence the rivers come, thither they return again.
- All things are full of labour; man cannot utter it: the eye is not satisfied with seeing, nor the ear filled with hearing.
- The thing that hath been, it is that which shall be; and that which is done is that which shall be done: and there is no new thing under the sun.
- Is there any thing whereof it may be said, See, this is new? it hath been already of old time, which was before us.
- There is no remembrance of former things; neither shall there be any remembrance of things that are to come with those that shall come after.
This passage was taken from the King James Version, because if you're quoting the Bible you might as well go with the most dramatic version.
The Case Study of Vanitas Yenpress Edition Volume Facts
It's the fiddly details.
The Volumes and Their Mémoires in Sequential Order
Volume 1 (published 12/20/2016)
- Mémoire 1 Vanitas In the Event of Rusty Hopes
- Mémoire 2 Noé In the City of Flowers
- Mémoire 3 Jeanne The Hellfire Witch
- Mémoire 4 Femme Fatale Love
Volume 2 (published 5/23/2017)
- Mémoire 5 Archiviste Fans That Reveal Blood
- Mémoire 6 Altus Other World
- Mémoire 7 Bal Masqué Night of Sneering Masks
- Mémoire 8 Louis Sinking in a Pool of Blood
- Mémoire 9 Réminiscence Friends
- Mémoire 10 Salvatio Uncertainty
Volume 3 (published 11/14/2017)
- Mémoire 11 Deux Ombres Point of Departure
- Mémoire 12 Pause
- Mémoire 13 Glissando Glissando
- Mémoire 14 Catacombes Where the Dead Sleep
- Mémoire 15 Chasseur Those Who Hunt Crimson
Volume 4 (published 8/21/2018)
- Mémoire 16 Galopp At the End of the Riot
- Mémoire 17 Cicatrice No. 69
- Mémoire 18 Dos-à-dos The Shape of Salvation
- Mémoire 19 Serment Spellbound
- Mémoire 20 Serment Promise (Part I)
- Mémoire 21 Serment Promise (Part II)
Volume 5 (published 1/22/2019)
- Mémoire 22 Hurler A Calling Voice
- Mémoire 23 Au Pas Camarade Pace
- Mémoire 24 Forêt d’argent Chance Encounter
- Mémoire 25 Endroit Approprié Melee
- Mémoire 26 Dissonance Creaking Laughter
- Mémoire 27 Cage de Neige Dregs
- Entracte Chambre d’enfants A Dream of the Sound of Rain
Volume 6 (published 12/24/2019)
- Mémoire 28 Dal Segno Question Mark
- Mémoire 29 Château de Sorcière The Witch and the Youth
- Mémoire 30 Strascinando Tremolo
- Mémoire 31 Oiseau et Ciel The Vampire of the d’Apchiers
- Mémoire 32 Visiteur Footfalls of the Beast
- Mémoire 33 Cauchemar Rumble
- Mémoire 34 Jean-Jacques The Vampire of the Chastels
Volume 7 (published 7/21/2020)
- Mémoire 35 Louisette Pillar of Justice
- Mémoire 36 Chasse aux Vampires The Beast
- Mémoire 37 Vengeance Hands That Touch a Nightmare
- Mémoire 38 Naenia She Who Harbors Death
- Mémoire 39 Poupée Fissurée The Essence of the Witch
- Mémoire 40 Avec toi Alone Together
Volume 8 (published 6/15/2021)
- Mémoire 41 Canorus Snow Flower
- Mémoire 42 Encore une Fois Love
- Mémoire 43 Encens Restant Lingering Scent of the Dream
- Mémoire 44 Mal d’Amour The Incurable Illness (Part 1)
- Mémoire 45 Mal d’Amour The Incurable Illness (Part 2)
- Mémoire 46 Un Autre Scar
Volume 9 (published 6/6/2023)
- Mémoire 47 Hétérogène Sneering Laughter
- Mémoire 48 Rencontre Blue Night
- Mémoire 49 Douleur Kind Child
- Mémoire 50 Petrichor The Thread that Reels in the Past
- Mémoire 51 Tempest A Silent Scream
- Entracte Jours Bruyants Tales of Lost Children
Volume 10 (published 10/17/2023)
- Mémoire 52 Sens unique Fall
- Mémoire 53 Pleavoir Rain Which Doesn’t Know the Sky
- Mémoire 54 La nuit sans lune Dark Night
- Mémoire 55 Après la pluie His Wish
- Mémoire 56 Faire un gâteau Bittersweet
Volume 11 (published 4/22/2025)
- Mémoire 57 Au revoir Again, Someday
- Mémoire 58 Observation The Darkness In Between
- Mémoire 59 Fuga What the Organist Plays
- Mémoire 60 Bonne journée Sweets, Complaints, and Reconciliation
- Entracte Couche On Clothing
- Mémoire 61 Jeau de paume Court Tennis
- Mémoire 62 Bourdonnement Wingbeats of Scattered Thought
Brocante 2009-2015 Vanitas and Noé